A few weeks back I read James Clear’s book Atomic Habits and while I don’t think the book is a must-read, Clear made some interesting points that have led me to re-evaluate my relationship to my work computers.
The key insight from Atomic Habits is that even small percentage improvements in your life and work can lead to major changes as the benefits accrue over time 1. Going to bed 10 minutes earlier might only make you feel 1% better during your next morning workout, but that 1% added up across a year’s worth of workouts might be difference between you having six-pack abs or not.
So, what does that have to do with my tech setup? Well, since the introduction of the Butterfly keyboards on Pro Mac laptops in 2016, I’ve been on a bit of an odyssey to see if I should adopt Windows or Chromebooks as my work laptops. The Butterfly keyboard is notoriously unreliable 2, and I lived in fear that my MacBook Pro would have a keyboard failure while I was traveling, and that I’d have to be without it for 2-3 weeks while it was being repaired. Luckily, that hasn’t happened 3, but my MacBook Pro still feels fragile. Meanwhile, Windows and ChromeOS laptops are diverse enough that you can easily find reliable great-feeling keyboards.
Last winter I bought a Pixelbook, and started moving my client work to Amazon’s Cloud9 service. Cloud9 gives you an IDE in a web browser tab, and using it has meant that I essentially have the same work environment from any computer with a decent web browser 4. It’s a great weight off my shoulders knowing that my work isn’t tied up to one computer with a keyboard that could fail at any time, and I think I’ll keep using a system like this going forward for the peace of mind.
However, the rest of the experience of using a Chromebook is frustrating in a lot of small ways. On a Chromebook I’ve run into hard limits with design software. I have clients that send me Photoshop files, and I can access them in an emergency using the awesome web app Photopea, but it doesn’t support all of Photoshop’s features or even custom fonts. Figma is a great alternative to Sketch, but it also lacks custom fonts on ChromeOS. I’m phasing out using FTP to deploy projects, but I still need it for many of my older projects that I help maintain. Sadly, I’ve yet to find an FTP client as nice as Transmit or Cyberduck for ChromeOS. The most pervasive annoyance is that system-wide keyboard shortcuts aren’t customizable, so moving between a Mac and ChromeOS can be frustrating 5.
I have an aging Windows PC I used for gaming, and using it for work is simply unpleasant. Software updates happen when Microsoft wants them to happen, even if you’d really like to get something done. Just about everything in Windows seems like it was hit with an ugly stick. Font rendering is particularly jarring after using a Chromebook or Mac. On the bright side, I can use Photoshop, Figma (with custom fonts), and Cyberduck, but the rest of the app ecosystem is sorely lacking. With the exception of FTP and design software, I’d actually say ChromeOS has a superior app platform thanks to the introduction of Android and Linux applications.
While I can make both of those platforms work in a pinch (thanks largely to Cloud9), I’ve realized, because of Atomic Habits, that those little annoyances are subtracting small percentages of efficiency and productivity from my daily work. So, today I’ve decided that my tech wanderlust is over. I’m sticking to the Mac because it should benefit my work over the long run. And luckily for me, Apple finally fixed the keyboards.
And I personally think the Butterfly keyboard feels awful. ↩
Instead, I had to have my 2016 MacBook Pro replaced with a 2017 because the battery started swelling. Getting a replacement took Apple a month. ↩
Sadly, that does not include the iPad. ↩
I wish I could swap alt tab for ctrl tab on a Chromebook. ↩